Economist Sanjeev Sanyal raised a stark critique of societal priorities after a information report surfaced a few student in Kolkata who sat for her board exam despite losing her mom in a highway accident.
In a publish on X (previously Twitter), Sanyal shared the report and wrote, “We all know now we have lost the plot as a society when a baby is made to really feel that some board exam is extra necessary than the demise of her mom.”
In response to the report, the Class X student lost her mom in a highway accident simply earlier than her ICSE math exam. With the assist of the police, she nonetheless made it to the exam corridor and accomplished her check.
Sanyal’s publish sparked widespread debate. Whereas some referred to as for a systemic overhaul, others argued that the student’s determination was a harsh reflection of actuality.
One consumer commented, “I feel the student did the proper factor. It exhibits maturity. Would it not actually be good that she fails in a topic she devoted a 12 months to? It’s solely three hours. I respect the child.”
Sanyal responded, clarifying that his concern was not with the little one however with the societal mindset that justified such a scenario. He wrote, “Nothing unsuitable with the little one. She would have been in trauma and did no matter adults suggested her. My drawback is with the wider society that justifies this (esp when a supplementary exam system exists and she or he may have taken the exam after two months). This isn’t a case the place the mom occurred to have handed away not too long ago. She died on the method to the examination corridor.”
One other consumer remarked, “Board exams are okay, however now we have introduced them to a stage the place we expect they’re every part and supreme.”
Some steered structural adjustments, equivalent to shifting to a SAT/ACT-style system that enables exams all through the 12 months as an alternative of a single high-stakes day.
Others highlighted the broader implications of the system. “Ten years down the line, when that child has a spot in lecturers, firms would sideline her. Nothing to do with society. Simply exhibits the place the child put her priorities. Needs to be appreciated for her personal good,” wrote one consumer.
One other echoed the sentiment of harsh actuality: “That’s the brutal reality, isn’t it? Our system doesn’t pause for private loss — it forces you to decide on between heartbreak and a ticking clock. She selected the clock, not as a result of it damage much less, however as a result of the world wouldn’t wait.”
Some customers identified related pressures in the office. “There are various situations when firms have refused go away even when somebody’s father has died. Folks have been requested to resign. There isn’t a worth of human life in our nation — everyone seems to be in a race to the high.”
Others shifted the blame to the schooling system itself. “No, Sanjeev. Society has not lost the plot. The system has failed society. Lacking the exam is just not a selection for Indian college students.”
One other consumer summarized the deeper concern, writing, “The trendy schooling system has been decreased to a way of survival. The system has instilled a lot concern that with out trendy schooling, you can not survive. They’re promoting levels, not the true knowledge this nation was constructed on.”
Source link
#Weve #lost #plotSanjeev #Sanyal #calls #outsocietal #failureas #student #sits #exam #losing #mom
