Google reserves key search data for Gemini, not rival AI apps

Google final yr started providing some synthetic intelligence companies a strategy to anchor chatbot responses in its search outcomes, however nonetheless reserves key options for its personal AI service, Gemini, an organization govt testified.

Liz Reid, Google’s head of search, was describing in court docket Tuesday how the Alphabet Inc. unit handles requests for its data for use by synthetic intelligence fashions.

Google has been pushing again on a proposal by the U.S. Justice Division that the corporate shares a lot of the data it collects to construct its search outcomes. Reid’s testimony that Google’s present practices favor its personal AI service could bolster arguments by antitrust enforcers for a extra stage taking part in area.

Beginning in Might 2024, Google started providing a “grounding” service inside Vertex AI, its app developer platform provided by Google Cloud, which permits AI fashions to examine Google’s net outcomes as a part of producing a response to extend its accuracy. Greater than a dozen corporations now use the service, based on court docket paperwork proven in court docket, although the names had been redacted from public show.

In response to questions by a authorities lawyer, Reid acknowledged a disparity between what corporations obtain once they pay for grounding through Vertex and what Gemini will get as a part of the Google household.

“The net outcomes it supplies are the identical,” Reid stated of Vertex AI. However Google “is offering extra outcomes” to Gemini within the type of search options just like the Information Graph, which describes relationships between entities, or the OneBox, which provides instantaneous outcomes to some queries like sports activities scores or flight data.

Reid, who took over as head of search in 2024, has overseen among the most significant adjustments to Google Search in years, together with the rollout of AI Overviews, through which the corporate makes use of AI to reply on to some search queries.

Final yr, U.S. District Choose Amit Mehta discovered the corporate illegally monopolized the net search market. He’s presently holding a three-week listening to on what adjustments he ought to order to Google’s enterprise to treatment the unlawful conduct.

The Justice Division has requested that Mehta drive Google to share a lot of the data the corporate collects to construct its search outcomes. That might permit AI corporations to assist develop their very own search indices to offer grounding.

AI startup Anthropic PBM has requested some extra entry to Google’s search data for its Claude mannequin, based on the paperwork, however Reid stated she wasn’t certain if that has been authorised. Google has invested about $3 billion in Anthropic, which additionally has funding from Amazon.com Inc.

Meta Platforms Inc. Chief Govt Officer Mark Zuckerberg has stated publicly that his firm’s AI fashions use Google for grounding. Earlier within the trial, an OpenAI govt stated the ChatGPT maker approached Google final August about utilizing its search index, however the Alphabet unit declined.

Throughout her testimony, Reid stated the Justice Division’s data-sharing proposal—which she referred to as “intensive and invasive”—would offer rivals with “an enormous treasure trove of data” that will doubtless make them the goal of hackers. She additionally estimated that as many as 2,000 Google engineers can be diverted from enhancing Google’s merchandise to compliance points if the Justice Division’s proposal had been adopted.

Beneath questioning, Reid acknowledged that she hadn’t shared that estimate internally, calling it a “tough estimate” she created in session with Google’s authorized staff on the case.

Reid was additionally crucial of the company’s proposal that will permit web sites extra means to choose out of Google’s AI merchandise. Google already provides web sites some opt-out means, she stated, however the granularity of the DOJ’s proposal can be “difficult” to implement as a result of the corporate does not all the time use totally different fashions for every function.

2025 Bloomberg L.P. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.