The rookie catcher constructed some buzz throughout spring coaching, however he was the clear third catcher in the beginning of the season and commenced at triple-A. When Alejandro Kirk’s thumb fracture prompted a surprisingly early MLB debut on April 5, Valenzuela was a profession .201/.294/.315 hitter at triple-A. The projection system ZiPS predicted that if he noticed MLB motion in 2026, he’d give the Blue Jays an identical .207/.274/.338 line.
Whereas Valenzuela hasn’t been a world beater, his .222/.300/.429 slash line is sweet for an above-average 105 wRC+, and his 0.7 fWAR ranks third amongst Blue Jays place gamers. Together with these offensive numbers has come some sturdy defensive work, even when there have been hiccups, like his run-scoring throw into left discipline on Monday.
Valenzuela’s efficiency — together with the profound offensive struggles of Tyler Heineman, whose wRC+ at present sits at 0 — has many Blue Jays followers questioning if he’s able to take over because the staff’s backup catcher when Kirk returns. Not solely that, however his multi-faceted contribution to the Blue Jays has raised questions about whether or not his ceiling could be increased than it appeared when the staff first acquired him in a low-profile commerce for Will Wagner ultimately yr’s commerce deadline.
It’s too early to make definitive declarations on that, however Valenzuela’s first 25 video games within the massive leagues provide some clues about the kind of participant he would possibly develop into, each offensively and defensively.
Whereas Valenzuela’s first 70 journeys to the plate have been productive, a rookie’s first impression offensively isn’t at all times consultant of what they provide in the long run.
Blue Jays historical past has many notable examples of gamers who seemed good offensively in small samples as rookies, solely to carry out considerably worse within the years to return. Listed below are just a few examples:
Even the participant Valenzuela was traded for, Wager, would possibly find yourself becoming this description. The infielder hit .305/.337/.451 in 86 plate appearances as a rookie for the Blue Jays in 2024, slashed .225/.324/.279 between Toronto and San Diego the following yr, and hasn’t been seen within the majors in 2026.
At this level, Valenzuela’s MLB outcomes don’t tell us a lot about what he may be offensively, although he’s come by them actually and has anticipated numbers that carefully match his manufacturing with a .243 xBA and .418 xSLG. There’s a motive the ZiPS projection system, which noticed him struggling a lot on the plate in 2026, has him hitting simply .208/.277/.347 from right here on out. Maybe it’s too gradual to react to his numbers with the Blue Jays, however the fundamental concept is that the physique of labor is simply too small for it to alter issues a lot.
Whereas the outcomes are a faint optimistic signal, among the underlying numbers for Valenzuela are intriguing. That begins along with his uncooked energy. The toughest-hit ball he’s managed this season (111.4 mph) is effectively above common.
Solely 95 of the 386 hitters with 25-plus batted balls this season have managed one thing tougher, and solely 10 of these gamers are catchers.
That energy ceiling is held up by above-average bat pace, significantly from the fitting facet, the place his common swing (72.5 mph) is nearly a full mph quicker than the MLB common (71.7 mph). These traits additionally pair effectively with a bent to maintain the ball within the air, as he’s run a groundball price beneath 40 per cent in 4 straight minor-league seasons earlier than 2026, and that quantity sits at 38.1 per cent early in his major-league profession.
If given enough at-bats, Valenzuela is prone to put just a few balls over the fence; the massive query for him is whether or not he could make sufficient contact. His strikeout price thus far (28.6 per cent) is excessive, and never prone to drop an excessive amount of contemplating he maintained a price between 23 and 25 per cent in every of his final 4 minor-league seasons — and MLB pitching is considerably tougher to make contact with.
His whiff price (30.2 per cent) can also be effectively above MLB common (25 per cent), largely attributable to a heavy chase price that’s additionally effectively above the league commonplace (34.2 per cent vs. 28.5 per cent). It’s potential that is one thing that adjustments with time, but it surely’s price remembering that Valenzuela is in his age-25 season and the basics of his hitting model are much less prone to shift than they might be for a 21-year-old breaking by means of for the primary time.
On a micro degree, it’s intriguing that Valenzuela has collected all of his extra-base hits in opposition to secondary pitches whereas slugging simply .207 in opposition to fastballs and .188 vs. four-seamers particularly. If he can’t do something with exhausting stuff, that will probably be a catastrophic concern, but it surely’s far too early in his profession to imagine that development will proceed. For instance, Kazuma Okamoto struggled to generate exhausting contact in opposition to something gradual when he was first adjusting to the MLB sport, till he discovered his footing.
It’s spectacular that Valenzuela is holding his personal within the majors offensively. Only a few rookie catchers do this. Within the final 50 seasons, 384 rookie catchers have had 50 or extra plate appearances, and simply 22.8 per cent managed a wRC+ of 100 or higher. He’s working with some actual energy, and his inclination to raise the ball ought to assist be certain that energy evolves into tangible manufacturing.
The query with him is prone to be how a lot constantly he can faucet into that energy, and the way a lot strikeouts might drag down his total offensive contribution.
Whereas Valenzuela has caught simply 175 innings within the main leagues, the outcomes thus far have been wonderful throughout the board per Statcast metrics, regardless of a comparatively excessive error whole (3).
His 5 Fielding Run Worth at present ranks eighth amongst all MLB place gamers regardless of his restricted taking part in time. Whereas it’s tough to gauge how a lot of that’s small-sample-size noise, it’s notable that he got here to the Blue Jays with a sterling defensive fame. For instance, MLB Pipeline described him as an “spectacular receiver” who “manages a pitching employees effectively” and thought of a 15 house run energy ceiling greater than sufficient if his defence remained “such a power”.
It’s not possible to make certain of a catcher’s true expertise in framing or blocking on the highest degree based mostly on so few MLB video games, however, notably, what we’re seeing from Valenzuela in these areas is in step with the ability set he demonstrated over 3,414 minor-league innings earlier than reaching Toronto.
The framing, particularly, has jumped off the web page as only one catcher within the majors (Patrick Bailey) can high his +3 framing runs. For slightly additional context on how massive a distinction maker he’s been on this space, listed below are Valenzuela’s called-strike numbers in opposition to a mean framing catcher — on this case, Nick Fortes, of the Tampa Bay Rays.
Whereas that’s spectacular, the pattern is simply too small to be assured that Valenzuela will stick with it. An space the place his prowess is simpler to be assured in is controlling the working sport. Even after struggling a bit with the Rays this week, the 25-year-old has thrown out 31.8 per cent of base runners, effectively above the MLB common (23.7 per cent). The underlying numbers are additionally wonderful.
Valenzuela’s pop time of 1.89 ranks tenth amongst 62 catchers who’ve tried to catch at the very least 5 runners at second base, due to a throwing velocity of 84.9 mph that ranks ninth. The time it takes him to uncork his throws after he catches pitches (0.62 seconds) isn’t as excellent, however nonetheless effectively above common, rating nineteenth in that group. These numbers don’t say something about his accuracy, however his sturdy profession minor-league caught stealing price (32 per cent) and among the performs he’s made with the Blue Jays counsel that he can put the ball the place it must go.
In his temporary time with the Blue Jays, Valenzuela has offered stellar defence, regardless of a few noteworthy blunders. His glove was his calling card when he was acquired, and his temporary MLB profession has solely offered confirmatory proof that good issues occur when he straps on the instruments of ignorance.
Simply 25 video games into his profession, it’s too early to render a verdict on what Valenzuela will probably be within the majors. It is sufficient to decide that he has instruments that stand out amongst his friends, even on the sport’s highest degree. Not solely that, however his standout expertise — uncooked energy and defensive ability behind the plate — are among the most respected an MLB participant can have. That doesn’t imply he’s on his technique to dethrone Alejandro Kirk sometime, or develop into an elite commerce asset like Gabriel Moreno, however the Blue Jays have each motive to be inspired by what they’ve seen thus far.
Source link
#thenumbers #Blue #Jays #rookie #catcher #Brandon #Valenzuela
